Skip navigation

Media statement on RDT: David Heilpern

profile image
Cate Faehrmann
NSW Greens MP
3 June 2021

David Heilpern is a retired NSW Magistrate having sat in regional and rural NSW for over 20 years. He is an Adjunct and Practice Professor at Southern Cross University, and is Director of “Drive Change” an organisation dedicated to law reform in the area of drug driving, with particular emphasis on prescribed cannabis patients.

“I have viewed photographs of the drug tests on Cate Faehrmann MLC on the weekend of Nimbin Mardi Grass 2021. It is immediately apparent from those photographs that police were not complying with their own standard operating procedures. They were not wearing gloves.

The Standard Operating Procedures for random oral fluid testing are found on the NSW Police website[i]. Paragraph 1-5 could not be clearer or more directive:

“Under no circumstances will oral fluid or equipment used to obtain oral fluid samples be handled by police without wearing protective latex or nitrile gloves”.

It beggars belief that the only test that was conducted on that day where protocols were breached was the one on a member of parliament, and it is far more likely that protocols were contravened extensively in the operation that occurred. Press reports state that there were more than 1500 tests conducted around Nimbin during the Mardi Grass with 29 detections[ii].

The consequences of the breach are significant.

First, all tests conducted without gloves and in breach of the protocols would be unlikely to be able to be successfully prosecuted for obvious reasons[iii].

Second, all subsequent tests on other people would also be suspect – the protocols have been developed to protect from cross contamination and not wearing gloves means that the testing regime is unreliable.

Third, evidence obtained as a result of this impropriety (including stage two and three testing) would be subject to inadmissibility rulings in court proceedings under s138 of the Evidence Act NSW.

I join calls for all prosecutions or penalties launched or issued as a result of the flawed testing withdrawn. This is not only because any prosecution would be likely to fail, but also out of a recognition that it would be unfair to proceed.

Finally, these 1500 tests were conducted on unimpaired[iv] festival goers and locals going about their business. It is a colossal waste of police time, community resources and road safety funding for this to have occurred in the first place. It was not and does not even pretend to be about road safety. It is all about prohibition. For this to have transpired in circumstances where the police cannot even follow their own clear directives amplifies the absurdity of the entire operation.”

 


[i] https://www.police.nsw.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0020/612704/4761_information_for_the_disclosure_log.pdf

[ii]https://www.nbnnews.com.au/2021/05/03/dozens-test-positive-for-drugs-at-nimbins-mardi-grass/

[iii] See for example: https://www.smh.com.au/national/nsw/sydney-lawyer-has-drug-driving-charge-dismissed-after-police-drug-test-contamination-20190807-p52epa.html

[iv] The reason that we can assume they were unimpaired is that if they were impaired, the police would have charged them with a more serious offence: See Standard Operating Procedure 1.4

profile image
Cate Faehrmann
NSW Greens MP
3 June 2021
SHARE:

THE LATEST NEWS

MEDIA RELEASE

Govt Puts Gambling Industry First by forgoing $1 Billion in gambling tax revenue

The state budget handed down today is yet more proof that the Minns Government cares more about the interests of the gambling industry than it does the people of NSW, says Greens MP and gambling harm reduction spokesperson Cate Faehrmann.

MEDIA RELEASE

Auditor-General Report confirms Government is failing to reduce poker machine harm

A Performance Audit by the NSW Auditor-General released today into the Regulation of Gaming Machines exposes the Minns Government’s ongoing failure to effectively regulate poker machines in order to reduce the substantial harm they cause, says NSW Greens MP and gambling harm reduction spokesperson Cate Faehrmann.

PARLIAMENT

Road Transport Amendment (Medicinal Cannabis-Exemptions from Offences) Bill 2025

As The Greens spokesperson for drug law reform and harm reduction, I am proud to once again introduce a bill into this place that seeks to right an injustice in our road laws that makes criminals out of thousands of people in this State for doing nothing wrong. The Road...

MEDIA RELEASE

Minns must stop dragging his feet on Warragamba flood mitigation measures

As Hawkesbury residents brace themselves for the threat of yet another flood, Greens MP and water spokesperson Cate Faehrmann has renewed calls for the NSW Government to act on recommendations to use Warragamba Dam as a flood mitigation tool. 


CAMPAIGNS